Three months ago, the CMO of a founder-led software company doing about $60 million left after a tense budget review. This is a composite. Since then the agency has kept the campaigns running, sent the monthly report and joined the leadership meeting once a month. This week its renewal arrives with a bigger scope: more channels, a strategy workstream, and a fee about a third higher. The founder's first instinct is to sign. The agency knows the account and the board wants pipeline. It feels like the safe choice.
It may be. But look at what has happened quietly since the seat opened. The agency that runs the work is now also choosing what to do and reporting on how it went. Nobody inside the company is in a position to tell it to do less.
The budget, worked through
Gartner's 2026 CMO Spend Survey, fielded January through March 2026 among 401 marketing leaders in North America, the U.K. and Europe, put marketing budgets at 7.8% of company revenue, up from 7.7% in 2025. Paid media reached a five-year high of 31.4% of the budget, labor rose to 24.5%, and martech fell to a five-year low of 19.4%. We read those figures as reported by Chief Marketer (June 24, 2026) and MarketScale (September 5, 2026). Gartner's own page would not load for us, so check the primary before you cite it. Neither summary gave a 2026 agency share. For that we use Gartner's 2025 figure of 21.0%, as summarized in Uptempo's State of the CMO Seat 2026, a vendor report.
Apply those shares to the $60 million company:
| Line | Share | On a $4.68M budget | Who plans it with the seat empty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid media | 31.4% (2026) | $1.47M | Agency |
| Labor (in-house team) | 24.5% (2026) | $1.15M | Whoever the team reports to now |
| Agencies | 21.0% (2025) | $0.98M | Agency |
| Martech | 19.4% (2026) | $0.91M | Whoever signed the contracts |
Paid media plus agency fees on a $4.68 million budget: about 52% of the money, planned, bought and reported by the agency once the CMO seat is empty. Worked example, directional.
ETHOSLINK calculation from Gartner shares (2026 and 2025) as reported by Chief Marketer, MarketScale and UptempoTreat this as directional. The shares come from two survey years and don't add to 100%. Gartner's respondents are mostly large companies; Uptempo describes the sample as organizations with median revenue above $1 billion. A $60 million company may spend a different share of revenue and split it differently. The mechanism still applies. When the seat is empty, roughly half the money is planned by the firm paid to spend it.
That isn't a criticism of agencies. They are paid for the work they do, so they can't be the ones to suggest doing less of it. That's the job of whoever owns the plan.
The martech line has its own quiet problem. MarketScale reports that 56% of Gartner's respondents increased the share of martech budget going to consumption-based pricing in the past year, and that half of the organizations using it are continually renegotiating contracts. Usage-priced tools need someone watching the meter. In many companies that person was the CMO.
Three questions for the first two weeks
- Who holds admin rights? List the ad accounts, analytics, CRM and website. For each one, check whether the company or the agency is the owner. If the agency owns them, fix that first, whatever else you decide.
- What renews in the next six months? List every agency and martech contract, its renewal date, its notice period and who signed it.
- What did the agency recommend cutting last year? If the answer is nothing, that's useful information.
Four doors
Fix. The founder or CEO takes the plan back, with a strong marketing operations lead holding the contracts and the data. The agency works to a written brief and reports against measures it didn't set. This works when the strategy is settled and someone senior has real time for it.
Bridge. A fractional CMO holds the seat for a set term, often a few days a week. In the first 90 days they take back the accounts, review the agency's scope and the martech contracts, and set the measures. They also write the brief for a permanent CMO if one is needed. A confidential search can run at the same time.
Stay fractional. If the agency does most of the execution and the plan is steady, the company may not need a full-time CMO at all. A fractional leader sets strategy and holds the agency accountable over the long term. Recheck that call each year.
Search now. If marketing is the main growth engine, if the brand is the product, or if the team needs a leader every day, start a confidential, retained search now. A fractional CMO can hold the seat while it runs.
The bigger retainer is a fifth option, and sometimes it's the right one. It makes sense once someone inside owns the plan. Until then, more scope means the agency is setting more of the plan.
What this is not
It isn't an argument against agencies, which often do the work better than an in-house team could. And it isn't an argument for always hiring someone. Plenty of companies run well with a fractional CMO and a good agency for years. The point is the order of decisions. Settle who owns the plan, then size the retainer.
Write the rule down. Name the door, record why, and set a review date, usually at the next renewal. We covered the other half of this decision, pricing the role by the budget it controls, in The 4.1-Year CMO, and the case where the CMO leaves after a budget review in The CMO After the Budget Review.