Insight · Leadership Pipeline

The Nine-Year CEO and the Succession Control Map: Who Owns Each Decision in a Confidential Succession

This is a composite. The CEO of a privately held manufacturer doing about $250 million has run the company for nine years. Over breakfast, he tells the board chair, in confidence, that he wants to step down in about 18 months. He has thought it through. Two internal leaders could be ready. He offers to run the process himself: develop both, recommend one, and keep it quiet so the business doesn't wobble. The chair is relieved, says yes, and agrees to keep the rest of the board informed.

That yes hands over nearly every input the board will use to decide. The CEO writes the development plans, sees both candidates every day, decides what the board hears, and sets the timing. Both candidates report to him. None of this needs bad faith. It's how the setup works.

A quieter market, and longer tenures

Fewer CEOs are leaving right now, and the ones who leave have been in the job longer. Russell Reynolds' Global CEO Turnover Index counted 101 CEO departures across the major global indices in the first half of 2026, down from 118 a year earlier. That is the lowest first-half total in the index's nine years. Average tenure for the CEOs who left was 9.0 years, up from 6.6 a year earlier, and 88% of incoming S&P 500 CEOs were internal appointments.

9.0 years

Average tenure of CEOs who left the major global indices in the first half of 2026, up from 6.6 years a year earlier. Departures were the lowest first-half total in nine years of tracking.

Russell Reynolds Associates, Global CEO Turnover Index, August 13, 2026

The US numbers point the same way. Challenger, Gray & Christmas counted 1,337 announced CEO exits through September 2026, down 19% from 1,650 in the same period of 2025. Of the replacements named, 53% came from inside the company, up from 49%. Challenger also counted 102 interim CEOs leaving so far this year, up 70% from 60. That figure tells us interim arrangements are ending more often. It doesn't tell us why.

The two series measure different things. Russell Reynolds tracks the largest listed companies worldwide, and Challenger counts announcements from US organizations of every kind. Neither covers private mid-market companies specifically. We can't say whether these patterns hold for a $250 million private manufacturer. What carries over is the setup. When a CEO has been in the seat nine years and the successor is likely internal, the CEO knows the candidates far better than the board does.

The control map

A succession comes down to about eight decisions. The board doesn't have to make every one itself, but it should decide on purpose who does. Here's a default map. Change it if you need to, but write the changes down.

DecisionDefault ownerOutgoing CEO's roleWhere it drifts
Timing and the announcement dateBoard chairProposesThe CEO's preferred date becomes the plan
Scorecard for the next CEO (the strategy 3 to 5 years out, not today's job)BoardMajor inputThe scorecard describes the current CEO
Internal candidate listBoardRecommendsOnly the CEO's two names are considered
Development plan for each internal candidateCEOOwns, reports to the boardRarely a problem; the CEO is best placed
Assessment against the scorecardIndependent adviser or search partnerOne inputThe CEO's view is the only view
External benchmark slateBoard, through a retained search partnerInformed, not involvedSkipped, so the board never sees an alternative
Who knows, and whenBoard chairAgrees the listThe circle grows one breakfast at a time
The outgoing CEO's role after the handoverBoardNegotiatesDecided last, under time pressure
The CEO should shape the candidates. The board should own the measure they are judged against.

Eighteen months, in three stretches

Months 18 to 12. The chair names a small committee, usually two or three directors. The board writes the scorecard for the strategy the company is heading into, then compares it with the CEO's own view and settles the differences on paper. The committee agrees who knows. In a confidential succession that list should be short enough to say aloud. For how these circles leak, see The Confidential Search.

Months 12 to 6. The CEO develops the internal candidates against the scorecard. An independent assessment gives the board a second read. If the board wants a benchmark, a retained search partner runs a confidential external slate. The internal candidates may or may not be told, and the board should decide which in advance. Boards often end up more confident in an internal choice once they've seen the alternatives.

Months 6 to 0. The board decides. The outgoing CEO's next role is settled before the announcement, not after: chair, adviser for a fixed term, or a clean exit. Then the transition plan for the new CEO starts. This is where executive coaching earns its fee, because a new CEO stepping up from inside has to lead former peers, often with the former boss still in the building.

What this is not

It isn't distrust of the CEO. The best successions have the outgoing CEO closely involved, and a CEO who raises it 18 months early is doing the board a favor. Plenty of boards reach the same choice the CEO would have made. The difference is that the board can explain how it got there.

It also isn't an argument for an outside hire. Most successions at large companies go to insiders, and that's often the right answer. An external slate is a benchmark, not a vote against the internal candidates. If the board decides it doesn't need one, write that down too.

The process rule is the same one we use for any seat. Fill in the control map at the first committee meeting, record why the board made each choice, and set a review date at the six-month point. For what usually goes wrong when boards start late, see What Boards Owe the Next CEO. For a board that has already set a twelve-month deadline, see The Board Wants a CEO Successor in 12 Months.

Frequently asked

Questions about this analysis

Who should run a CEO succession process?

The board, usually through the chair or a small committee. The outgoing CEO should be deeply involved, especially in developing internal candidates, but the decisions that pick the successor (the scorecard, the assessment and the final choice) belong to the board.

Should the outgoing CEO assess internal candidates?

Their view is essential, and it should be one input. Internal candidates report to the CEO, so an independent assessment by an outside adviser or search partner, measured against the board's scorecard, gives the board a second read.

Is CEO turnover rising or falling in 2026?

Falling, on the two main measures. Russell Reynolds counted 101 CEO departures across major global indices in the first half of 2026, the lowest first-half total in nine years of tracking. Challenger, Gray & Christmas counted 1,337 US CEO exits through September 2026, down 19% from the same period of 2025.

Why run an external search if we have an internal candidate?

To give the board a benchmark. A confidential external slate shows what the market offers against the internal candidate, and boards often end up more confident in an internal choice once they have seen it.


Planning a CEO succession?

We help boards set the scorecard, benchmark internal candidates confidentially and run the retained search when one is needed. For the incoming leader, our executive coaching covers the first months in the seat.

Book a Discovery Call